Ahead of the Shaking

Earthquake ground-motion prediction

Ahead of the shaking

The first stations to record an earthquake already hold clues about what everyone else is about to feel. This work turns those first seconds into predictions: the peak shaking at stations the waves have not reached yet, and the rest of each waveform while the earthquake is still unfolding.

Begin Each line behind this text is a seismometer, ordered by position. Click anywhere to start an earthquake there.
3stations to issue a forecast
~10 sto a refined waveform
M4–9any magnitude, any epicentre
01Seconds of warning save lives

An earthquake early-warning system cannot stop the shaking. It buys the seconds needed to stop trains, shut off gas, park lifts and take cover, and real earthquakes show what those seconds are worth.

Fire
~86%

Of about 105,000 dead or missing in the 1923 Great Kantō earthquake, about 90,000 died in the fires that followed.

Cabinet Office of Japan, 2023 [1]

Fire
~80%

Share of 1906 San Francisco losses caused by fire: about $400M in total against $80M from shaking alone.

Derived from USGS figures [2]

Gas
3million

Tokyo Gas meters that shut off automatically in the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake, triggered at about 200 gal.

Norito & Inomata, 2012 [3]

Rail
19trains, 0 derailed

Shinkansen trains on 11 March 2011 began emergency braking about 10 s before strong shaking arrived.

Government of Japan, 2013 [4]

Rail
204km/h

Speed of the Toki 325 when it derailed near the 2004 Chūetsu epicentre; none of 154 aboard were injured.

JTSB RA2007-8 [5]

Rail
70→26mph

BART trains automatically brake on an earthquake alert, a system in place since 2012.

BART, 2014 [6]

Water
<1minute

A ShakeAlert-connected water utility closes reservoir valves in under a minute; integration cost about $17,000.

PNWS-AWWA [7]

Power
122of 398

Fires after the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake that were electrical in origin, across 17 prefectures.

PreventionWeb, 2011 [8]

Trust
94of 95

ShakeAlert alerts for M4.5+ events, Oct 2019 to Sep 2023, that were real earthquakes.

USGS 70263400 [9]

People
>50%

Share of Loma Prieta (1989) injuries caused by falls; in Northridge (1994) over half came from falling objects.

Allen & Melgar, 2019 [10]

People
15s

Warning on Japan's east coast in 2011. JMA issued its alert 8.6 s after first detection.

JMA; USGS [11]

Responders
125stations

LA County Fire stations testing ShakeAlert to recall elevators, alert radios and start generators automatically.

Early Warning Labs / PNSN [13]

With this much warning, these actions finish in time

10 s
0 s30 s

Action times are illustrative assumptions for this demonstration, not measured values.

02How the forecast works

Three steps run every second while the earthquake unfolds. The simulation below shows all three at once.

1 · Detect

P waves travel at about 6 km/s, S waves at about 4 km/s. The gap between them grows by roughly one second for every 8 km of distance.

2 · Predict across space

The first stations' P waves, distance to the rupture and station geometry give a PGA forecast for stations not yet reached.

3 · Complete through time

Each station's recorded waveform is extended forward and refined every second as new data arrive.

The research is trained and tested on recorded strong-motion data from the NGA-West2 database, using rupture distance (Rrup) to relate each station to the fault. On this page, shaking levels follow BSSA14, a ground-motion model built from the same database, with realistic scatter between events and between stations. Every waveform is built from real recorded earthquakes: real P-wave windows and S-wave trains, aligned to each station's arrival times and scaled to its shaking, so that any epicentre and magnitude can be explored.

Alder Fault simulatorM7.2 · 10 km deep
T+0.0 s
Layers
Recording video…

Stage 1 · The stations

Shaking forecast across the stations, second by second

First detection––
Forecast issued–3 stations + 1.5 s
Warned before S––
Blind zone–no warning possible

Stations

Click or drag along the fault to choose where the rupture starts.

Key
P wavefront S wavefront Station, filling as the waves cross it PGA forecast, wave not arrived Rupture; arrows show the two sides sliding Shaking intensity (MMI 4–9)
M7.2

Record section

In order of arrival, first station at the bottom, as in the NGA-West2 plots.

Key
Recorded so far Model prediction, refined each second Uncertainty PGA forecast range (wave not arrived) Recorded truth (T)

Stage 2 · What the warning buys

Every town acts on its own forecast

Alert sent––
People warned––
Est. injured––
Evacuated––

Early warning map

Population (each figure is 25,000 people), critical infrastructure, and forecast then recorded PGA at each site.

Key
Power flowing Switched off safely Gas flowing Sparks or gas fire Train (speed in km/h) ≈ forecast PGA at a site Recorded PGA at a site
–

Decisions

Each place acts on what it has, its forecast shaking and its seconds of warning.

0safe in time 0partly ready 0caught by shaking –people warned

Stage 3 · Report, ready when the shaking stops

M7.2 on the Alder Fault

–
ASummary

–

BTown reports

Estimated consequences in the four towns, from the shaking each one received. With early warning, people who get about 5 s or more can Drop, Cover and Hold On, gas valves close and power is cut before the shaking, so fewer people are hurt by falls and falling objects and fewer fires start.

Illustrative estimates from empirical loss curves of the PAGER type (Jaiswal & Wald), tuned to a modern, well-built region; 2.6 people per building. Real losses depend on building stock, time of day and local soils.

CActions taken

Warning time for each town, the shaking it received and how many of its safety actions finished before the S wave arrived.

DForecasts across space

Every earthquake is a bit stronger or weaker than average for its size. The first three stations' P waves reveal how this one compares. The model applies that to the expected decay of shaking with distance and forecasts peak ground acceleration (PGA) at stations tens of kilometres away, before the S wave gets there. Real stations scatter around any forecast, so each forecast carries a range.

Figure 1.PGA against distance to the rupture. Dashed: BSSA14 median for this magnitude. Amber: the model's estimate for this event.
Figure 2.Forecast against recorded PGA per station. Shaded band: within a factor of 2.

–

EWaveforms through time

Once a station's own P wave arrives, the model extends its recorded trace forward in time. The first forecasts are rough. They are refined every second, and about 10 seconds after the P wave they follow the true waveform closely. The amber band is the model's uncertainty.

–

FReferences
  1. Cabinet Office of Japan, White Paper on Disaster Management 2023, special feature
  2. USGS, 1906 San Francisco earthquake: casualties and damage
  3. Norito & Inomata, 15th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, 2012
  4. Government of Japan, Highlighting Japan, March 2013
  5. Japan Transport Safety Board, Railway Accident Investigation Report RA2007-8
  6. BART, McPartland congressional testimony, 2014
  7. PNWS-AWWA, ShakeAlert and Water Systems
  8. PreventionWeb, Lessons from Japan quake show importance of quake circuit breakers
  9. USGS, ShakeAlert performance, publication 70263400
  10. Allen & Melgar, Earthquake Early Warning: Advances, Scientific Challenges, and Societal Needs, 2019
  11. JMA, Technical Report 133; USGS, Tōhoku early warning times
  12. USGS, Entire US West Coast now has access to ShakeAlert
  13. Early Warning Labs / PNSN, ShakeAlert deployment sheet
  14. Federal Laboratory Consortium, ShakeAlert provides critical seconds of warning; USGS, Fact Sheet 2014-3083
  15. USGS, Earthquake Early Warning overview
  16. Boore, Stewart, Seyhan & Atkinson (2014), NGA-West2 equations for PGA, PGV and PSA, Earthquake Spectra 30(3)
  17. Worden et al. (2012), Relationships between ground-motion parameters and MMI in California, BSSA 102(1)
  18. Jaiswal & Wald (2010), An empirical model for global earthquake fatality estimation, Earthquake Spectra 26(4)
  19. Wells & Coppersmith (1994), Relationships among magnitude, rupture length, rupture width and displacement, BSSA 84(4)

The region, stations, towns, population and infrastructure are fictional. Shaking levels follow the published BSSA14 ground-motion model; waveforms and model forecasts are simulated for demonstration and are not real recordings or results from the research model. The statistics in section 01 are real and sourced above.

Video

The film, and your own run

The 3½-minute film tells the story in ten parts: what early warning is, why seconds matter, how the forecast works on a real earthquake's records, this dashboard and its three stages, our research on national television in Chile, and the papers behind it. To film your own scenario, set it up on the dashboard and press Record; it records to the end as long as this tab stays open, then Download appears.

Nothing recorded yet.